Larry Ellison Donates $500,000 to Sderot: Thanks, But Isn’t It the Government’s Role to Protect the People?

Larry Ellison, billionaire CEO of Oracle Software, has pledged $500,000 in aid to the Israeli border town of Sderot.

Accompanied by Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni and US congressman Tom Lantos (D-CA), Ellison made the pledge upon hearing that the Sderot community center was not fortified from bombs and offered to pay for its protection.

Whose Responsibility to Fortify Sderot?
Personally, I wonder about the implications of such an investment for international relations and relationships, particularly as they affect Israel and the United States.

Although Ellison is a private individual, the community center in Sderot is a public entity. While it is true that Ellison is not buying the center, only ensuring its continuity, what does it mean for the government of Israel to be seeking donations from Westerners? Is it not a primary job of the government to provide protection for its people? What are the consequences of a private person stepping in to take on such a role?

Arcadi Gaydamak

The same has been asked of Arcadi Gaydamak’s ongoing support for Israelis in crisis. Although full discussion of Gaydamak will be saved for a future post, it is important to note him as an example in our discussion of the roles of private individuals and the government.

During the long days of the Second Lebanon War, Gaydamak donated $15 million (the equivalent of $500,000 a day) to establish tent villages for Northerns who evacuated. In November 2006, he funded a week long trip for residents of Sderot to Eilat, Israel’s seaside resort, to give them a break from the constant barrage of bombs from Gaza.

These donations were met with awe at their generosity and scepticism at their intent as Israelis pondered Gaydamak’s future political plans.

The Role of Private Individuals versus the Government

Both Ellison’s donation to Sderot and Gaydamak’s ongoing support to Israelis in their times of need are to be gratefully appreciated for their direct results. But it does lead one to wonder: what is the role of the government and what is the role of a private citizen?

Ellison did not happen upon the Sderot community center, but was guided there by one of the most powerful players in Israeli politics.

In my post on Charity versus Philanthropy, I stated that philanthropists step up when the government isn’t able to fulfill its role in protecting the people and bridging social divides.

Is that what is happening here? If so, what are the long term implications of Israel’s dependency on foreigners, even foreigners from among the Nation of Israel?

9 Responses to Larry Ellison Donates $500,000 to Sderot: Thanks, But Isn’t It the Government’s Role to Protect the People?

  1. Samuel M. Prince says:

    There are a lot of needs in this world. And, there are a lot of things governments provide. BUT, it should never be missed by us, of all people, that governments do things for their own reasons, usually political. Representative governments do this even more so.

    I long ago gave up on the notion that Jewish (Israeli) government was any less susceptible to the financial and political pressures than any other democratic govenment is when it comes to spending money. In other words, most democratic forms of government are variations on the woreld’s oldest profession and simply cannot be counted on to do the right thing at the right time.

    Mr. Ellision’s reason’s for his $500,000 gift may be pure beneficence. Or, they may be pure self interest. Only time will tell. But, to the people in Sderot, I am reasonably certain, no matter the underlying motivations, the results are greatly appreciated just the same.

  2. […] A note on my last post, “Larry Ellison Donates $500,000 to Sderot: Thanks, but Isn’t It the Role of the Governme… […]

  3. thenewjew says:

    Samuel,

    I agree with your comment wholeheartedly. Only time will tell Mr. Ellison’s intentions, but in the meantime, the whole community is sure to benefit.

    I must add that I admire the work of LANWT and was glad to learn of it.

    Thank you for your thoughts.

    Maya

  4. […] “Larry Ellison Donates $500,000 to Sderot: Thanks, but Isn’t it the Government’s R… […]

  5. dudubisskitz says:

    After 9/11, Americans were told the following: Muslims hate us for our freedoms, and that curtaling American freedoms was the purpose of the attacks. 7 Years later and no bearded or turbaned muslim has attempted to take away my freedom, but I will never forget this man, Larry Ellison trying to severely curtail American freedom by offering his technology to institute national I.D. cards along with the the creation of databases. Many then fantasized about a U.S. that would be more like Israel: no freedom of movement, intense domestic spying and intelligence, draconian measures for “safety” etc. etc. I say no thank you, I can deal with fear knowing that at least I have freedom. I would rather be murdered by extremists than live one day without freedom. It seems now that it was the Jews who “hated us for our freedoms…”

  6. Thanks for the solid work and good luck with the site, I look forward to future updates.

  7. These are genuinely enormous ideas in concerning blogging. You have touched some fastidious
    things here. Any way keep up wrinting.

  8. At this time I am ready to do my breakfast, when having
    my breakfast coming again to read further news.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: